朱迪斯·巴特勒：哲学的第三类接触

• 别名：JudithButler:Philosophicalencountersofthethirdkind
• 清晰：BD
• 类型：家庭
• 主演：
• 年代：2006 / 法国 /
• 导演：
• 国家/地区：法国
• 时长：120分钟
• 语言/字幕：国语对白 中文字幕
• 年代：2006
• 更新时间：2024-04-08 01:28:22
• 影视/评论：当前有0条评论，
• 详细介绍： JudithButler:PhilosophicalEncountersoftheThirdKind… JudithButler:PhilosophicalEncountersoftheThirdKind DirectedbyPauleZajdermann FirstRun/IcarusFilms ThetitleofthenewdocumentaryonfeministtheoristJudithButlerplaysuponDr.J.AllenHynek’shypothesisthattherearethreepossiblekindsofencounterswithaliens:thefirstkindisdefinedas“sighting,”thesecondas“evidence”andthethirdas“contact.”Thetitlenotonlysuggeststhattheintentionofthedocumentaryistomake“contact”with“JudithButler,”butthat,moretothepoint,somethinghasprohibitedthiscontact.Theobjectiveofthedocumentary,therefore,is“topopularize[Butler’s]insightfulanalysisofsexualidentityandgenderroles”sothatcontactcanbemadebetween“us”and“her,”theimaginary,inaccessibleOther.Consequently,theresultisthatthepasttwentyyearsofButler’sworkisreducedintodigestiblephrases:“peopleareanxiousaboutgender,”“genderisalwaysaboutambivalence”and“genderisalwaysafailure.” Forthoseof“us”whoengagewithButler’sworkonascholarlylevel,thisdocumentarywillbeunsatisfactory;thereisnocriticaldiscussionofButler’smostcontestedideasaboutgender,performativity,howshenegotiatesvarious(andseeminglydisparate)theoriesintoherowncriticalmethodologyortheproblematicsignificanceofHegelianrecognitioninhertheoriesonidentityandethics.Insteadofestablishingcontactonaphilosophicallevel,thedesireistomakecontactwithButleronapersonallevel.ThusthefilmopenswithButlerdescribingherselfasa“problemchild,”whoskippedclassesanddid“terriblethings,”andendswiththecameralingeringslowlyoveraphotoofherwithherpartnerandson. ThecurrencyofacademiainAmericaseemstobeinitsvalueasentertainment-inscholarsascelebrities,whenmorselsabouttheirprivatelivescanbeincludedinthepagesofPeopleMagazine.ItisnowonderthenthatwearetoldatlengthaboutButler’sfamilyowningmovietheatresinCleveland,orthathermotherislikeJoanCrawford.Inoneparticularlyintriguing,albeituncomfortable,scene,Butlerdiscusseshercelebritystatus,theinvasionofherprivacybythepressandthatsomecriticismshereceivesisbothpersonalandpainful.Herfrustrationwiththeexpectationthatshemustembodyherowntheoryfunctionsasironiccommentaryonthedocumentaryitself.ItalsoraisesthequestionaboutwhatcompelledButlertodothedocumentary—whatkindofcontact,andatwhatprice? ReviewedbyMarcieBianco 茱蒂絲．巴特勒，國際當紅的後結構女性主義者、酷兒理論學者、哲學家。猶太人，現任美國加州大學柏克萊分校（UCBerkeley）比較文學系主任、修辭學與比較文學教授。除了她的哲學思想，片中也描述她的童年，如何在一個飽受性別規範暴力的猶太家庭中成長。事實上，《性別麻煩》中的理論，正是她從小時候家庭成員的互動中觀察而來。片中呈現巴特勒幽默風趣的談吐，以及過人的機智與魅力。 详情